7 September 2026

When Should You Send Wine Back at a Restaurant?

You’re at a restaurant. The wine arrives. The waiter pours you a small taste and waits. You swirl. You sniff. You sip.

And then comes the moment of truth. What exactly are you supposed to be deciding?

Despite what decades of slightly intimidating restaurant rituals may have led us to believe, that first taste isn’t really an invitation to decide whether you like the wine. It’s primarily your chance to check that the wine is in good condition.

And yes, sometimes you absolutely should send wine back at a restaurant. Other times, you may simply have ordered a wine that isn’t your cup of tea. Or glass of wine, as the case may be.

When you absolutely should send wine back

Wine can have genuine faults, and you shouldn’t feel awkward about speaking up if something clearly isn’t right.

The wine is corked

A corked wine has been affected by a compound commonly known as TCA. It can smell like damp cardboard, a musty cupboard or a wet basement, and the fruit can seem strangely muted.

Importantly, finding bits of cork floating in your glass doesn’t mean the wine is “corked”. That’s just an unfortunate encounter between a corkscrew and a cork.

The wine is oxidised

Too much exposure to oxygen can leave wine tasting flat, tired or stale. Whites may appear unusually dark or brownish and can develop bruised-apple or sherry-like characteristics that aren’t supposed to be there.

There are deliberately oxidative wine styles, of course, so context matters.

The wine has been heat damaged

Wine doesn’t enjoy being cooked any more than we do. Poor storage or excessive heat can damage it, leaving the wine tasting dull, stewed or strangely lifeless. A cork pushed upwards in the bottle or signs of leakage can sometimes be clues.

If you suspect any of these faults, politely ask the sommelier or waitperson to check the wine. You don’t need to deliver a courtroom argument. A simple, “I think there might be something not quite right with this wine – would you mind having a taste?” is enough.

When you probably shouldn’t send it back

Here’s where things get murkier. You order an unfamiliar Cabernet and discover it has much firmer tannins than you expected. You choose a Chardonnay and realise it’s richer and oakier than the style you normally drink.

Or perhaps the wine is perfectly sound…

You just don’t like it.

Generally, that isn’t a fault with the wine. If you chose the bottle yourself and it matches what was described, the restaurant hasn’t done anything wrong. Wine is enormously subjective, and occasionally we’re going to order something that simply isn’t for us.

There is one important exception. If you’ve explained exactly what you like to the sommelier – “I’d love something light, fresh and delicate with very little oak” – and they recommend something big, buttery and heavily oaked, it’s perfectly reasonable to have a conversation about it.

That’s one reason good sommeliers ask questions rather than simply pointing you towards the most expensive bottle.

What about wine by the glass?

This one’s slightly different. If a wine has been open too long, it can lose its freshness well before it becomes obviously undrinkable.

If your glass tastes flat or tired, particularly when you know the wine or variety reasonably well, it’s fair to ask when the bottle was opened. A good venue won’t be offended.

And what if you’re not sure?

Ask.

You don’t need a wine qualification, an encyclopaedic vocabulary or the ability to identify “forest floor after autumn rain” at 20 paces. Just say something doesn’t taste quite right and ask the sommelier or waitperson to check it.

Wine should be enjoyable, not an exam.

And if the wine turns out to be perfectly sound but simply not to your taste? Chalk it up to experience. You’ve just learnt something useful about what you don’t like.

Sometimes that’s every bit as valuable as discovering what you do.

Mike Davies And Kim Mckee - Cofounders Greenskin Wine

Cheers!

Mike and Kim

quality assurance guarantee

We stand firmly behind the quality of our wines and offer our money-back guarantee – your ticket to a risk-free wine adventure. See full details here Quality Assurance Guarantee.

Want to know more?

Cart
Buy 3 or more cases & get free shipping!
Use Mamamia Code:
MAMAMIA10
for 10% OFF
your first order
Greenskin Wines Travel
Use Mamamia Code:
WINETIME10
for 10% OFF
your first order
Greenskin Wines Travel
Greenskin Wine Favicon
you look so young!
are you over 18?

By clicking YES, I am declaring that I am over 18 years old.