Intimidated by the Wine List? How to choose a great bottle.
The wine list arrives. Twenty pages. Six countries. Dozens of producers. Grape varieties you’ve never heard of. And a few bottles approaching the price of a domestic flight.
Where on earth do you start?
If you’ve ever felt slightly intimidated by a restaurant wine list, you’re certainly not alone. Even people who know and enjoy wine can find themselves staring blankly at a list packed with unfamiliar producers, regions and vintages.
The good news is you don’t need encyclopaedic wine knowledge to choose well.
You don’t need to understand the whole wine list. You just need a few clues to find something you’re likely to enjoy.
Start with what you already know you like
Forget trying to decipher every bottle on the page. Start with yourself.
Do you generally enjoy whites or reds? Lighter or fuller-bodied wines? Crisp and refreshing or rich and round? Fruity or savoury? Lots of oak or very little?
Even knowing a couple of varieties you regularly enjoy gives you a useful starting point. If you usually drink Sauvignon Blanc, you might look for something fresh, aromatic and high in acidity. If Pinot Noir is your thing, chances are you enjoy lighter reds rather than huge, powerful ones.
You don’t have to know why you like them. Knowing that you do is enough.
And knowing what you don’t like can be just as useful. “I don’t like really heavy reds”, “I’m not keen on heavily oaked Chardonnay” or “I find really tannic wines a bit much” can eliminate a sizeable chunk of the wine list straight away.
Use regions as a shortcut
One of the most useful tricks is knowing that certain wine regions have built their reputations around particular varieties and styles. It doesn’t guarantee you’ll love every bottle, but it can significantly improve your odds.
If you see Margaret River Cabernet Sauvignon, for example, you’re looking at one of Australia’s great combinations of grape and place. Great Southern Riesling is another classic Australian pairing, known for wonderfully fresh, aromatic wines with bright acidity, while Tasmania has become renowned for cool-climate Pinot Noir and sparkling wine.
Further afield, Marlborough is famous for Sauvignon Blanc, Burgundy for Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, Barossa Valley for Shiraz and Mendoza for Malbec.
You certainly don’t need to memorise the wine world. But recognising a handful of varieties and the regions famous for producing them can be an excellent shortcut through a complicated list.
Price can be a clue - but you don’t need to spend a bomb
Let’s tackle the awkward one.
Does a more expensive wine mean a better wine?
Sometimes, yes.
Higher prices can reflect better quality fruit, lower vineyard yields, more labour-intensive production, expensive oak, longer maturation, limited production or simply the cost and reputation of the vineyard or region. So price can be an indicator of quality.
But the relationship is far from perfect. Once you get beyond a certain point, rarity, prestige and demand can have an enormous influence on price. A $150 wine is certainly not guaranteed to give you three times the enjoyment of a $50 bottle.
And there are excellent wines sitting at the more affordable end of a good restaurant list.
Rather than thinking, How much do I need to spend to get something decent?, decide what you’re comfortable spending first. Then look for the best option within that range.
Don’t be embarrassed to tell the sommelier your budget
If there’s a sommelier or knowledgeable waitperson, use them. In fact, on a really interesting wine list, they can be your best shortcut.
You can simply say:
“We’re looking for a red around $70 to $90. We like Pinot Noir and lighter Shiraz. What would you recommend?”
That gives them something genuinely useful to work with and is far better than pretending price doesn’t matter while silently panicking when they point to a $180 bottle.
If you’d rather not announce your budget to the table, point to a wine at roughly the price you’re comfortable with and say:
“We were thinking somewhere around here.”
They’ll understand.
A good sommelier isn’t there to make you spend the most money. They’re there to help you find something you’ll enjoy.
Give them three clues and let them do the work
If you really don’t know where to start, there’s an even easier approach.
Tell the sommelier:
- What you normally like.
- What you’re eating.
- Roughly what you want to spend.
.
That may be all they need.
For example: “I normally drink Sauvignon Blanc, we’re having seafood and pasta, and I’d like to stay around $80.”
You don’t need to identify the grape, country or vintage yourself. That’s their job.
In fact, giving a good sommelier a little freedom can lead you towards something you would never have chosen on your own.
Tell them what you’re eating – but don’t obsess over pairing
Food is another very useful filter. You don’t need to memorise complicated pairing rules. Tell the sommelier what everyone is ordering and let them help narrow the field.
If half the table is having seafood and the other half pasta, ask for something versatile. If everyone has ordered steak, that immediately points things in another direction.
But don’t become obsessed with finding the theoretically “perfect” match. There are usually plenty of wines that will work beautifully with a meal.
And sometimes the best wine to order is simply the one everyone at the table is going to enjoy.
Don’t dismiss the unfamiliar bottle
This is where restaurant wine lists can get really interesting.
A good wine list isn’t simply a catalogue of famous labels. Often the person who created it has hunted down smaller producers, interesting regions and lesser-known varieties specifically because they think they’re worth drinking.
So if you see a grape you’ve never heard of, ask about it.
If you usually drink Pinot Noir, ask whether there’s an unfamiliar variety with a similar weight and style. If you love Sauvignon Blanc but feel like trying something different, say so.
Rather than treating unfamiliarity as a risk, use what you already know you like as the reference point.
You may discover a new favourite.
And don’t automatically order the second-cheapest wine
There’s a long-standing belief that restaurants put their biggest mark-up on the second-cheapest bottle because people don’t want to look stingy by ordering the cheapest.
Don’t build your wine strategy around it.
Restaurant pricing varies enormously, and on a well-chosen list the least expensive wine may be there precisely because the wine team thinks it offers terrific value.
Choose the wine, not its position on the price ladder.
Remember what the whole exercise is actually about
Wine can be incredibly complex. That’s part of what makes it fascinating.
But complexity shouldn’t make drinking it intimidating.
You don’t need to correctly pronounce every French region, understand the difference between 15 vintages or detect graphite, violets and freshly sharpened pencils before you’re qualified to choose a bottle.
Start with what you like. Use varieties and regions as clues. Set a budget you’re comfortable with. Tell the sommelier what you’re eating and what you definitely don’t enjoy. Then be prepared to try something new occasionally.
Because the goal isn’t to choose the bottle that makes you look like you know the most about wine.
It’s to choose the bottle everyone wants another glass of.
Cheers!
Mike and Kim
quality assurance guarantee
We stand firmly behind the quality of our wines and offer our money-back guarantee – your ticket to a risk-free wine adventure. See full details here Quality Assurance Guarantee.
Want to know more?